The arguments on what shelter to take on the CDT are very similar to those I consider for every trek. I have a great ultralight tent, the Zpacks Altaplex. It's only 18 ounces and provides bug, wind, and rain protection. The only thing I don't like about it is that it takes up a lot of volume (relatively speaking), and uses most of the space in the pack's front pocket when it's wet. It also requires a short, 3 oz extension to my trekking pole for setup (it requires a 58" tall pole).
As my alternative I have two cuben flat tarps: a Zpacks 8.5' x 10' at 7.75 oz and an HMG 8.5' x 8.5' at 11 oz. The Zpacks drawback is that it doesn't have as many edge tie downs as the HMG. On the other hand, it has 'enough,' and it provides better rain coverage for the head and foot of my sleeping bag. To handle wet ground and condensation, plus bugs, I have to also take a bivy. My favorite is an MLD Superlight with an all-net hood at 5.3 oz. So I could do a tarp/bivy combo and have to carry only 11 oz instead of the Altaplex 18.
I really love the openness of the tarp. But to offset it, the bivy is a bit confining. You cannot spread your legs out when you feel like it. And you have to be careful rolling over. Though, the quilt alone has those constraints when it's cold out. And obviously, your bug protection does not support sitting up.
The other drawback of the bivy is that you cannot spread out your other pack belongings inside the dry tent. I carry an extra cuben cloth as a ground cloth for those items. That's another 1.5 to 3 oz, depending on which size I take.
I have to say, my clear emotional preference is to take the tarp/bivy. When I used the smaller tarp, I spent a couple of nights holding up the bathtub edges of the bivy to stop rain splatter from getting on my quilt (the bivy top is only water resistant). I haven't had that problem with the larger tarp.
My rational aspect says to take the tent to better handle bad weather and bugs.
So about two out of every three days I plan to take the tarp/bivy, and the third day I plan to take the tent.
My guess is I will end up taking the tarp/bivy combo.
Thursday, March 8, 2018
Tuesday, March 6, 2018
CDT Pack: Zpacks vs HMG
I wanted to write about this some time back, but was busy with other things. My favorite pack for the last few years has been the Zpacks Arc Blast. It's a cuben fiber (Dyneema Hybrid now) pack that weighs just 19 ounces after adding some shoulder and waist pockets. It has a 60 liter capacity, and doesn't come any larger. The pockets on the waist belt are large and easy to open and close. The main side pockets on the pack are placed down at the bottom of the pack and support easy removal and insertion of water bottles. There's a big, wide pocket on the front (back) of the pack that you can use to carry wet items or anything you want available without opening the pack.
There are a couple of drawbacks to the pack. When I've carried food for a 7-night/8-day hike, it's been pretty difficult to get the pack closed. It has velcro across both edges of the top of the bag that you press together, then roll down to prevent precipitation getting inside the pack. Even though I pack light (<12 lbs base weight), the volume just wasn't enough for a large food carry. And on that 7-night trip, I went light on the food. If I wanted to carry extra food and water, there just isn't sufficient room in the main bag.
A second 'complaint' about the Arc Blast is that the side and front pockets are mesh. They worked great on good trails. But a couple of trips ago, I encountered a lot of blowdown. I sat my pack down on one break and leaned it against a downed tree. It looked good. But there was a very small wood pick that got caught in the mesh. It tore, and since then I've had unsightly tape keeping my belongings in the pocket.
The last, and usually unimportant drawback, is the waist belt fit. If you position it just right, its perfect. But even off a little on your hips, and it's a nagging irritant. I suspect related to the waist belt issue, is the fact that Zpacks doesn't recommend carrying over 25 pounds in the pack. That's been about my maximum, with food and water, so up till now it has not been a constraint on my trips.
A couple of years back, I decided to get a Hyperlite Mountain Gear 3400 Southwest pack. It is also cuben, has about a 60 liter capacity, and has the same set of pockets--sort of. The Southwest version of the pack uses solid cloth for the pockets instead of mesh.
Up until this year, I had not used the HMG pack more than once. The main reason was that the side pockets are raised up above the bottom of the pack. The difference is enough that it is nearly impossible to get a water bottle out of those side pockets without taking the pack off (younger folks may have a different experience). If you use a water reservoir with a tube, both packs will work fine for you.
The side pockets on the HMG seem to have a little more capacity than on the Zpacks. On the other hand, the waist belt pockets seem to be smaller and more difficult to access.
On the good side, the waist belt on the HMG seems to naturally fit into the right position on the hips almost the first time and every time. It just feels better than the continuous shifting required for the Zpacks pack.
Unfortunately, the HMG is also 13 ounces or so heavier than the Zpacks. To counter this, you get a load capacity of 40 pounds, 15 pounds greater than the Zpacks. You can probably fit more (larger) water bottles into the side pockets, but you will still have the same main bag volume limit.
HMG though, is ready for that. They also offer a 4400 Southwest pack with a taller main bag that provides about a 70 liter capacity. And they advertise a load capacity of 70 pounds!
Now the reason I'm posting this on my CDT page, is that I needed to make a decision on which pack to take. The issue I have with the Zpacks is that I expect to have to carry up to 6 liters of water, instead of my usual 2 liters or less, at least for portions of the trail in New Mexico. I will need both more volume and weight capacity than the Arc Blast will provide. There may also be food carries of 7 or 8 days, and if I last longer than on the AT, I may be eating more each day. So I will need more volume.
It may be a bit of overkill, but the 4400 Southwest seems to be the only choice I have (without going to other manufacturers).
Getting to my water is my main concern with the HMG. I've tried out a couple of solutions. One was an Evernew drinking tube that fit on their bottles, and other bottles with similar caps. I could use the tube from a bottle in the side pocket. But I really don't like tubes, and filling up a 1 or 1 1/2 liter bottle frequently with the weird tube caps would be a bit of a pain.
The alternative is to use a 16 ounce water bottle in a holster/pocket on the shoulder strap. I will probably have to take the pack off to refill it, but maybe not any more than I would for short breaks. I will have to change from using one of those shoulder pockets for my Steripen, but that's not a big drawback.
So while I could probably make my Zpacks work for the CDT, I'm going to go with the HMG to give me the margin I desire to carry more water and food.
There are a couple of drawbacks to the pack. When I've carried food for a 7-night/8-day hike, it's been pretty difficult to get the pack closed. It has velcro across both edges of the top of the bag that you press together, then roll down to prevent precipitation getting inside the pack. Even though I pack light (<12 lbs base weight), the volume just wasn't enough for a large food carry. And on that 7-night trip, I went light on the food. If I wanted to carry extra food and water, there just isn't sufficient room in the main bag.
A second 'complaint' about the Arc Blast is that the side and front pockets are mesh. They worked great on good trails. But a couple of trips ago, I encountered a lot of blowdown. I sat my pack down on one break and leaned it against a downed tree. It looked good. But there was a very small wood pick that got caught in the mesh. It tore, and since then I've had unsightly tape keeping my belongings in the pocket.
The last, and usually unimportant drawback, is the waist belt fit. If you position it just right, its perfect. But even off a little on your hips, and it's a nagging irritant. I suspect related to the waist belt issue, is the fact that Zpacks doesn't recommend carrying over 25 pounds in the pack. That's been about my maximum, with food and water, so up till now it has not been a constraint on my trips.
A couple of years back, I decided to get a Hyperlite Mountain Gear 3400 Southwest pack. It is also cuben, has about a 60 liter capacity, and has the same set of pockets--sort of. The Southwest version of the pack uses solid cloth for the pockets instead of mesh.
Up until this year, I had not used the HMG pack more than once. The main reason was that the side pockets are raised up above the bottom of the pack. The difference is enough that it is nearly impossible to get a water bottle out of those side pockets without taking the pack off (younger folks may have a different experience). If you use a water reservoir with a tube, both packs will work fine for you.
The side pockets on the HMG seem to have a little more capacity than on the Zpacks. On the other hand, the waist belt pockets seem to be smaller and more difficult to access.
On the good side, the waist belt on the HMG seems to naturally fit into the right position on the hips almost the first time and every time. It just feels better than the continuous shifting required for the Zpacks pack.
Unfortunately, the HMG is also 13 ounces or so heavier than the Zpacks. To counter this, you get a load capacity of 40 pounds, 15 pounds greater than the Zpacks. You can probably fit more (larger) water bottles into the side pockets, but you will still have the same main bag volume limit.
HMG though, is ready for that. They also offer a 4400 Southwest pack with a taller main bag that provides about a 70 liter capacity. And they advertise a load capacity of 70 pounds!
Now the reason I'm posting this on my CDT page, is that I needed to make a decision on which pack to take. The issue I have with the Zpacks is that I expect to have to carry up to 6 liters of water, instead of my usual 2 liters or less, at least for portions of the trail in New Mexico. I will need both more volume and weight capacity than the Arc Blast will provide. There may also be food carries of 7 or 8 days, and if I last longer than on the AT, I may be eating more each day. So I will need more volume.
It may be a bit of overkill, but the 4400 Southwest seems to be the only choice I have (without going to other manufacturers).
Getting to my water is my main concern with the HMG. I've tried out a couple of solutions. One was an Evernew drinking tube that fit on their bottles, and other bottles with similar caps. I could use the tube from a bottle in the side pocket. But I really don't like tubes, and filling up a 1 or 1 1/2 liter bottle frequently with the weird tube caps would be a bit of a pain.
The alternative is to use a 16 ounce water bottle in a holster/pocket on the shoulder strap. I will probably have to take the pack off to refill it, but maybe not any more than I would for short breaks. I will have to change from using one of those shoulder pockets for my Steripen, but that's not a big drawback.
So while I could probably make my Zpacks work for the CDT, I'm going to go with the HMG to give me the margin I desire to carry more water and food.
Monday, March 5, 2018
CDT Resupply and Food Planning
On my long AT section hikes, I did all resupply via USPS Priority Mail. I use ziplock bag cooking rather than using my pot to cook foods. That allows pre-portioned, individually ziplocked meals. But its a big hassle in preparation, and it put a big load on my wife to get the boxes ready and mailed.
The issue I have with resupplying on the trail, from grocery stores, is that you have to live with what's available. You either repackage foods or live with carrying extra packaging waste; you use valuable town time shopping and repackaging; foods can cost more; and you may end up carrying significant extra weight. And if you do ziplock food cooking, you'll have to carry extra ziplocks or throw away some of the ones you pay for.
If you mail, UPS, or Fed-Ex boxes, you can plan to meet your nutrition needs when you have the time and energy to spend on planning and food acquisition. By the way, a few of the resupply locations on the CDT do not accept USPS packages.
Well, I still want to plan ahead, address nutritional needs, and send boxes to resupply points. But I also want to make the box preparation as simple as possible. This time, in place of individual meals, vegetables, fruits, and snacks, I plan to bag each type of food for the full resupply period, and include empty ziplock bags as needed. I'll portion it out on the trail. Finding a desired food in the food bag is always an unexpected hassle--sometimes I have to pull out almost everything to find a food at the bottom of the bag. Presumably, this approach will make it easier to find the foods on the trail.
And more importantly, it should make boxing easier, and hopefully reduce volume. I know some people blog that they complete 28 boxes or so before they leave. I'm not sure how they tailor that to unexpected trail conditions and less or more miles and days than expected. If they change their alternate/official trail choices while on the trail, that can also very easily change the number of days a box (or boxes) would be expected to support.
I'm working my food plans now. I've never had hiker hunger on the trail, though when I get to towns I don't seem to have any problem eating way more than usual. So there seems to be a limit on the number of calories I can carry and expect to eat. And it will result in a significant calorie deficit. Protein is another issue. I plan to carry whey isolate to create a flavored protein shake/drink. I'll use vitamins of course to try and avoid vitamin and mineral deficiencies.
Variety is something I work pretty hard at, but there are limits imposed mainly from cost and prep time. I hope to mix Mountain House dehydrated meals with minute rice, ramen, and mashed potatoes. Probably half freeze dried and half of the quick carbohydrates each for the resupply. I've also got freeze dried vegetables and fruits that I will be taking. I can mix the vegetables in with the main meal. The dried fruits (bananas to start), can be eaten dried or rehydrated.
My breakfast planning has never succeeded. Or rather, I never follow my plan. When I get up, I want to pack up and hit the trail. I hate breaking out the stove again and spending a half hour cooking and eating. I do drink water, so I'm hoping a breakfast protein shake will survive trail execution. I'll either use granola/mil or breakfast bars to provide some extra calories, and I can eat those at my camp sight or my first on-trail quick stop.
Snack planning is also something that never really succeeds. Most of the food I still have when I get to the next town are snacks. Except for the Clif bars, I actually like most of the snacks. But I don't like long stops, and you can only snack so fast. My brief stops are usually about 5 minutes with a lunch stop of up to 20 minutes. My planned dinners make me full, so I don't have the appetite to eat unused snacks.
Bottom line here is that I do the best planning I can. But the plan will not likely survive the trail.
The issue I have with resupplying on the trail, from grocery stores, is that you have to live with what's available. You either repackage foods or live with carrying extra packaging waste; you use valuable town time shopping and repackaging; foods can cost more; and you may end up carrying significant extra weight. And if you do ziplock food cooking, you'll have to carry extra ziplocks or throw away some of the ones you pay for.
If you mail, UPS, or Fed-Ex boxes, you can plan to meet your nutrition needs when you have the time and energy to spend on planning and food acquisition. By the way, a few of the resupply locations on the CDT do not accept USPS packages.
Well, I still want to plan ahead, address nutritional needs, and send boxes to resupply points. But I also want to make the box preparation as simple as possible. This time, in place of individual meals, vegetables, fruits, and snacks, I plan to bag each type of food for the full resupply period, and include empty ziplock bags as needed. I'll portion it out on the trail. Finding a desired food in the food bag is always an unexpected hassle--sometimes I have to pull out almost everything to find a food at the bottom of the bag. Presumably, this approach will make it easier to find the foods on the trail.
And more importantly, it should make boxing easier, and hopefully reduce volume. I know some people blog that they complete 28 boxes or so before they leave. I'm not sure how they tailor that to unexpected trail conditions and less or more miles and days than expected. If they change their alternate/official trail choices while on the trail, that can also very easily change the number of days a box (or boxes) would be expected to support.
I'm working my food plans now. I've never had hiker hunger on the trail, though when I get to towns I don't seem to have any problem eating way more than usual. So there seems to be a limit on the number of calories I can carry and expect to eat. And it will result in a significant calorie deficit. Protein is another issue. I plan to carry whey isolate to create a flavored protein shake/drink. I'll use vitamins of course to try and avoid vitamin and mineral deficiencies.
Variety is something I work pretty hard at, but there are limits imposed mainly from cost and prep time. I hope to mix Mountain House dehydrated meals with minute rice, ramen, and mashed potatoes. Probably half freeze dried and half of the quick carbohydrates each for the resupply. I've also got freeze dried vegetables and fruits that I will be taking. I can mix the vegetables in with the main meal. The dried fruits (bananas to start), can be eaten dried or rehydrated.
My breakfast planning has never succeeded. Or rather, I never follow my plan. When I get up, I want to pack up and hit the trail. I hate breaking out the stove again and spending a half hour cooking and eating. I do drink water, so I'm hoping a breakfast protein shake will survive trail execution. I'll either use granola/mil or breakfast bars to provide some extra calories, and I can eat those at my camp sight or my first on-trail quick stop.
Snack planning is also something that never really succeeds. Most of the food I still have when I get to the next town are snacks. Except for the Clif bars, I actually like most of the snacks. But I don't like long stops, and you can only snack so fast. My brief stops are usually about 5 minutes with a lunch stop of up to 20 minutes. My planned dinners make me full, so I don't have the appetite to eat unused snacks.
Bottom line here is that I do the best planning I can. But the plan will not likely survive the trail.
Monday, February 26, 2018
Arguments For and Against Scot Peterson at Marjory Stoneman
I don't want to make this a long post (so it will be atypical), but one of the articles I was reading this morning really got to me. The Washington Times article was quoting some folks that said the officer that stayed outside Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School wouldn't have been able to stop the shooter because he had only a semi-automatic pistol. Now I don't know what the officer was carrying. He might have had something as nice as a semi-automatic Glock 17 with 17 or 18 rounds loaded in his gun and at least one backup magazine with another 17 rounds. The shooter had an AR-15 semi-automatic rifle with one presumes multiple 30-round magazines.
Now both weapons are semi-automatic and shoot one round with each pull of the trigger. The AR-15 is much more accurate at ranges of 25 yards or more. On the other hand, the AR-15, compared to a semi-automatic handgun, is unwieldy when you have to make significant aiming changes. So both officer and shooter could fire at the same rate.
In a school, you might encounter a long hallway, but one assumes the shooter was not spending most of his time in the hallway. In most areas of a school, the distance advantage of the AR-15 will not be present, and if it is, the person without the AR-15 should be able to back off to a short-range defensible position. Inside a building, one would assume the semi-automatic pistol would in most situations have an advantage or at least be equal to an AR-15.
Then too, you should take into account the relative training of the officer versus a young shooter. Maybe the officer never trained with his weapon, beyond annual qualifications. But he should have had some minimal tactical training. The officer should have had a skill advantage.
Bottom line, the officer should have had a reasonable chance of stopping the shooter. He should not have stayed outside. And folks should not be defending him by saying he couldn't have done anything anyway.
Now both weapons are semi-automatic and shoot one round with each pull of the trigger. The AR-15 is much more accurate at ranges of 25 yards or more. On the other hand, the AR-15, compared to a semi-automatic handgun, is unwieldy when you have to make significant aiming changes. So both officer and shooter could fire at the same rate.
In a school, you might encounter a long hallway, but one assumes the shooter was not spending most of his time in the hallway. In most areas of a school, the distance advantage of the AR-15 will not be present, and if it is, the person without the AR-15 should be able to back off to a short-range defensible position. Inside a building, one would assume the semi-automatic pistol would in most situations have an advantage or at least be equal to an AR-15.
Then too, you should take into account the relative training of the officer versus a young shooter. Maybe the officer never trained with his weapon, beyond annual qualifications. But he should have had some minimal tactical training. The officer should have had a skill advantage.
Bottom line, the officer should have had a reasonable chance of stopping the shooter. He should not have stayed outside. And folks should not be defending him by saying he couldn't have done anything anyway.
Sunday, January 21, 2018
Pork, CR's, Omnibus Bills, and Government Shutdowns
The post's title probably seems a bit broad. What do congressional pork, continuing resolutions, omnibus bills, and government shutdowns have to do with each other? Well, as usual, I'm going to ramble a bit before I get to the bottom line. So please bear with me.
Years ago, I thought pork added to Congress's bills was a waste of taxpayer money. I applauded when Congress decided to do away with most pork. You would get spending on a bridge, a road, a museum, a strange contract, or anything else the congress person thought was valuable to him or her. Most times, it probably was of benefit to his or her voters. Some times, it was likely a benefit only to a campaign contributor or to the congress person themselves. In my time in the military, I would see pork as direction to spend money on a specific contract and/or product. I didn't like that.
But my position has evolved. It was a useful tool to get votes in congress to pass a bill. In the past, I thought that was a good thing to get rid of. There were too many bills enlarging government and spending my money while at the same time reducing my freedoms. I thought, the fewer bills that were passed the better.
But there comes a point, and we've seen it since they did away with pork, where Congress doesn't seem able to pass even the minimum of bills necessary for the proper functioning of government. It used to be that they passed about 12 authorization and appropriation bills every year or two to fund the various parts of the government. One of those sets of bills kept the military going.
Instead, they now pass continuing resolutions (CR's). Basically, that means the government, and each of its sub-units is limited to the funding they received in the prior year, and only that portion (minus a percentage) due until the end of the temporary CR. You are not allowed to start any new projects; i.e., no new research and development, no new bridge, no new museum, etc. You also do not have any different level of funds in a given Program Element (PE). Appropriation bills, if my memory serves, specified how much money goes into each PE and what it could be spent on. With a CR, the PE cannot evolve. So if you have a research and development project that was doing some early development, and you are ready to build a more expensive prototype for testing, you won't have the additional funds needed. If you have refined your production process in a low-rate production contract and are ready to start producing at full rate, you cannot. You won't have the additional money needed. The government sub-unit has a limited capability to shift funds around. But anything significant, like redirecting from one PE to another, requires congressional approval. Essentially, a CR throws any kind of change and improvement in government planning and operations into chaos.
And why do they do CR's instead of authorization/appropriation bills? Because they cannot get the votes in the Senate to pass them. To vote on any bill, you need 60 votes to even get to the roll call. Sometimes a party preventing 60 votes is called a filibuster. In other cases, its just following the Senate's rules.
Now, after a few CR's each year, Congress seems to come to the conclusion that an omnibus bill is the only alternative to funding the rest of the year's government operations. Instead of living with last year's funding levels. They increase the level, across the board. Spending goes up, but without the fine tuning that the authorization/appropriation bills provided. I don't get my smaller government (its getting larger), and I also don't see refining and improved efficiency in any agency. In military procurement spending, I see crippled plans and reduced preparedness to fight any future wars.
But then there's the occasional problem with this smooth, sub-par process. One party or another decides they want something that the other party isn't providing. They vote down a CR and the government shuts down. With the Senate majority apparently limited to a 51-59 range, the majority party running the Senate does not have enough votes to get to an up or down vote on the CR. With no vote on the CR, there is no CR.
Without a CR, the government directs non-essential operations to be terminated. The rules seem to vary a bit, but excluding Obama's vindictive shutdown operations, most of the time any operations not involving public safety or ongoing military operations are terminated. The military keeps working, but 'without pay.' Even those not in essential operations. In one shutdown, I worked at a military laboratory. But 95% of the employees were civil service. I cleaned out my inbox and did paperwork while all of the civilians were sent home. We all assumed we would get paid once the shutdown ended (always true so far).
Some civilians look at a shutdown as a vacation. But it's only a vacation if you want to spend some unplanned time at home for an unknown period of time. You cannot travel; you have to return to work when the shutdown ends--and you do not know when that will happen. Plus, you are not getting paid. If you have a nice bank account level, that's not a problem. If you are younger or living paycheck to paycheck, it can have a serious impact.
But the shutdown, in essence, is just a political game between the parties. One party thinks the voter impact will aid their cause. Over time, the losing party, in public opinion, gives in and changes their position. Since the public opinion is based on what voters want, this usually means spending more money--pork!
And we are finally to my bottom line. Allow pork in bills again, and we can get a few votes swung, enough to offset political party and leadership pressure, and maybe get the authorization and appropriation bills through the Senate again. Sure, you spend a bit more, but at least to me, it seems worth it to offset the drawbacks of the CR's and the nearly unrestrained spending increases inherent in the omnibus spending bills.
Fewer CR's and omnibus bills also means fewer government shutdowns!
Years ago, I thought pork added to Congress's bills was a waste of taxpayer money. I applauded when Congress decided to do away with most pork. You would get spending on a bridge, a road, a museum, a strange contract, or anything else the congress person thought was valuable to him or her. Most times, it probably was of benefit to his or her voters. Some times, it was likely a benefit only to a campaign contributor or to the congress person themselves. In my time in the military, I would see pork as direction to spend money on a specific contract and/or product. I didn't like that.
But my position has evolved. It was a useful tool to get votes in congress to pass a bill. In the past, I thought that was a good thing to get rid of. There were too many bills enlarging government and spending my money while at the same time reducing my freedoms. I thought, the fewer bills that were passed the better.
But there comes a point, and we've seen it since they did away with pork, where Congress doesn't seem able to pass even the minimum of bills necessary for the proper functioning of government. It used to be that they passed about 12 authorization and appropriation bills every year or two to fund the various parts of the government. One of those sets of bills kept the military going.
Instead, they now pass continuing resolutions (CR's). Basically, that means the government, and each of its sub-units is limited to the funding they received in the prior year, and only that portion (minus a percentage) due until the end of the temporary CR. You are not allowed to start any new projects; i.e., no new research and development, no new bridge, no new museum, etc. You also do not have any different level of funds in a given Program Element (PE). Appropriation bills, if my memory serves, specified how much money goes into each PE and what it could be spent on. With a CR, the PE cannot evolve. So if you have a research and development project that was doing some early development, and you are ready to build a more expensive prototype for testing, you won't have the additional funds needed. If you have refined your production process in a low-rate production contract and are ready to start producing at full rate, you cannot. You won't have the additional money needed. The government sub-unit has a limited capability to shift funds around. But anything significant, like redirecting from one PE to another, requires congressional approval. Essentially, a CR throws any kind of change and improvement in government planning and operations into chaos.
And why do they do CR's instead of authorization/appropriation bills? Because they cannot get the votes in the Senate to pass them. To vote on any bill, you need 60 votes to even get to the roll call. Sometimes a party preventing 60 votes is called a filibuster. In other cases, its just following the Senate's rules.
Now, after a few CR's each year, Congress seems to come to the conclusion that an omnibus bill is the only alternative to funding the rest of the year's government operations. Instead of living with last year's funding levels. They increase the level, across the board. Spending goes up, but without the fine tuning that the authorization/appropriation bills provided. I don't get my smaller government (its getting larger), and I also don't see refining and improved efficiency in any agency. In military procurement spending, I see crippled plans and reduced preparedness to fight any future wars.
But then there's the occasional problem with this smooth, sub-par process. One party or another decides they want something that the other party isn't providing. They vote down a CR and the government shuts down. With the Senate majority apparently limited to a 51-59 range, the majority party running the Senate does not have enough votes to get to an up or down vote on the CR. With no vote on the CR, there is no CR.
Without a CR, the government directs non-essential operations to be terminated. The rules seem to vary a bit, but excluding Obama's vindictive shutdown operations, most of the time any operations not involving public safety or ongoing military operations are terminated. The military keeps working, but 'without pay.' Even those not in essential operations. In one shutdown, I worked at a military laboratory. But 95% of the employees were civil service. I cleaned out my inbox and did paperwork while all of the civilians were sent home. We all assumed we would get paid once the shutdown ended (always true so far).
Some civilians look at a shutdown as a vacation. But it's only a vacation if you want to spend some unplanned time at home for an unknown period of time. You cannot travel; you have to return to work when the shutdown ends--and you do not know when that will happen. Plus, you are not getting paid. If you have a nice bank account level, that's not a problem. If you are younger or living paycheck to paycheck, it can have a serious impact.
But the shutdown, in essence, is just a political game between the parties. One party thinks the voter impact will aid their cause. Over time, the losing party, in public opinion, gives in and changes their position. Since the public opinion is based on what voters want, this usually means spending more money--pork!
And we are finally to my bottom line. Allow pork in bills again, and we can get a few votes swung, enough to offset political party and leadership pressure, and maybe get the authorization and appropriation bills through the Senate again. Sure, you spend a bit more, but at least to me, it seems worth it to offset the drawbacks of the CR's and the nearly unrestrained spending increases inherent in the omnibus spending bills.
Fewer CR's and omnibus bills also means fewer government shutdowns!
Friday, November 10, 2017
Buck's Passing
Yesterday, we had our nearly 15-year old border collie, Buck, put to sleep. It was a hard decision, and a hard day. Buck was an extremely affectionate, male border collie of about 75 pounds. We brought him home as a pup, and I think he had a good life. We have five acres of land in Texas hill country, and we constantly have deer in our yard. They fascinated him. He came to me for cookies and went to my wife to play ball. He was definitely the smartest dog I've ever known. He would come into the den and either shake his head or put his head in my lap when he needed something. When I responded, he would stop at the front door, the food bowl, the (cookie) pantry, or sometimes just walk to the back door. In the 15 years we had him, I think he only had a mistake in the house three or four times--and I think those were due to feeling bad.
Unfortunately, in recent years his health had been declining. He had cancer on his tongue a couple of years ago, and lots of bleeding--though that had stopped. He had lost a lot of capability in his hind legs, and occasionally he had to be helped up if he was on the tile floor. We had to get a ramp to get him up into the sedan for his trips to the vet. He had also lost an eye a couple of years ago, and that made it harder for him to get around. He would trip every once in a while, and more frequently recently, go down when he did so. It was getting hard to get him to get up and go out. And he didn't seem to like any of his food anymore--unless we put something soft and new in it. And before our recent vacation, he had been coughing and choking a bit more frequently.
We always boarded him for our vacations. He actually seemed to like the kennel and the other dogs. This time, when we picked him up, they told us he was vomiting and excreting blood, and hadn't eaten for the last two days. He seemed pretty much himself, except he didn't want any cookies. He acted like he did, but he would just lick them and let them lay. He was vomiting occasionally on his walks, had diarrhea, and both had blood in them. We decided it was time to put him to sleep.
My wife called the vet around 9:30 am, and they wanted us to wait till 2:30 pm to bring him in. It was a tough several hours. We stayed with him while they administered the shots at the vet.
I found out if you cry a lot, don't take benadryl to put yourself to sleep. It results in a significant head-ache.
Part of my problem, in addition to loosing a dog that I really loved, was that I felt guilty. Was there something else we could have done to reduce some of his health problems? Better food and water or more vet care? Could we have gotten through this latest problem with patience and veterinary assistance? I don't know. I do know I don't think my wife could handle any further extended grief. Her dad's about to go into surgery, and both her parents are getting old. Her organization at work is going away, and she's got uncertainty there.
But this was the first time I had ever had a pet put down. We had cats and dogs when I was young and lived at home. But they either got hit by a car or ran off (a couple of the cats). The grief was sudden and short, and without any guilt. Before I got married, I avoided pets for the inconvenience of taking care of them--especially in apartments. But after we got married, my wife wanted a dog. We waited till we had some land for him/her, then she found a dog she wanted. Buck.
Having Buck pass brought back memories of my mother and father dying from cancer. Mom passed when I was in high school, from brain cancer. It was a long ordeal (inoperable), and we were at the hospital when she passed. It is very hard to lose her. Dad died just a few years ago. He had both lung and brain cancer. Again, they didn't operate, but Dad went through chemo. He had remarried and was living in Indiana near my step-mother's children (my wife and I were in Texas). He didn't seem to suffer like my Mom, though the chemo was pretty rough. He decided not to do another round of chemo. What was especially hard was that my sister and step-mother decided to move him to a nursing home just after Christmas that year--without consulting me. I would have preferred to bring him to Texas and our house, though he might not have wanted that. He died two weeks after being put in the home. During his chemo and my visits home, he seemed pretty much himself, though weaker and less active. As far as I was aware, he didn't get the excruciating pain my Mom went through.
But the point of discussing all of this (besides releasing some of my pain), is the fact that I have some measure of guilt associated with both Buck and my Dad in their passing. While I think I made the best decisions at the time, was there something more I could have done?
I don't plan on having another dog. They are great companions, but I don't want to go through the grief of their passing again.
Since I don't get many readers (including my wife), I thought I would add a comment or two on similar situations. I do not approve of abortion in most situations, nor of assisted suicide. In abortion, the girl, young lady, or woman, must either have a hard heart or live with some degree of guilt for their actions. I cannot imagine being in that position. But for their sakes, and those of their unborn child, I hope they decide to keep the child, or in the worst situation, put him/her up for adoption.
Assisted suicide is a little different. In that case, the person makes a choice that they do not want to live, and my libertarian leanings push me to accept their decision. In the terminal stages of a disease, with significant pain, I can understand that choice. But in any other situation, and even in that one, there may be other options for the future. Life has too many ups and downs to bail during one of the downs. If you lose a capability or some functionality, you work around it, just like in old age. It's helping the suicide that I believe is wrong; you should instead try to help them to get through the down time in their life. If you help, how can you live without guilt that maybe they would have recovered and lived years of enjoyable life?
If you read this, thanks for staying with me. Putting down my thoughts has brought me some relief. Maybe some day I will see Buck again...
Unfortunately, in recent years his health had been declining. He had cancer on his tongue a couple of years ago, and lots of bleeding--though that had stopped. He had lost a lot of capability in his hind legs, and occasionally he had to be helped up if he was on the tile floor. We had to get a ramp to get him up into the sedan for his trips to the vet. He had also lost an eye a couple of years ago, and that made it harder for him to get around. He would trip every once in a while, and more frequently recently, go down when he did so. It was getting hard to get him to get up and go out. And he didn't seem to like any of his food anymore--unless we put something soft and new in it. And before our recent vacation, he had been coughing and choking a bit more frequently.
We always boarded him for our vacations. He actually seemed to like the kennel and the other dogs. This time, when we picked him up, they told us he was vomiting and excreting blood, and hadn't eaten for the last two days. He seemed pretty much himself, except he didn't want any cookies. He acted like he did, but he would just lick them and let them lay. He was vomiting occasionally on his walks, had diarrhea, and both had blood in them. We decided it was time to put him to sleep.
My wife called the vet around 9:30 am, and they wanted us to wait till 2:30 pm to bring him in. It was a tough several hours. We stayed with him while they administered the shots at the vet.
I found out if you cry a lot, don't take benadryl to put yourself to sleep. It results in a significant head-ache.
Part of my problem, in addition to loosing a dog that I really loved, was that I felt guilty. Was there something else we could have done to reduce some of his health problems? Better food and water or more vet care? Could we have gotten through this latest problem with patience and veterinary assistance? I don't know. I do know I don't think my wife could handle any further extended grief. Her dad's about to go into surgery, and both her parents are getting old. Her organization at work is going away, and she's got uncertainty there.
But this was the first time I had ever had a pet put down. We had cats and dogs when I was young and lived at home. But they either got hit by a car or ran off (a couple of the cats). The grief was sudden and short, and without any guilt. Before I got married, I avoided pets for the inconvenience of taking care of them--especially in apartments. But after we got married, my wife wanted a dog. We waited till we had some land for him/her, then she found a dog she wanted. Buck.
Having Buck pass brought back memories of my mother and father dying from cancer. Mom passed when I was in high school, from brain cancer. It was a long ordeal (inoperable), and we were at the hospital when she passed. It is very hard to lose her. Dad died just a few years ago. He had both lung and brain cancer. Again, they didn't operate, but Dad went through chemo. He had remarried and was living in Indiana near my step-mother's children (my wife and I were in Texas). He didn't seem to suffer like my Mom, though the chemo was pretty rough. He decided not to do another round of chemo. What was especially hard was that my sister and step-mother decided to move him to a nursing home just after Christmas that year--without consulting me. I would have preferred to bring him to Texas and our house, though he might not have wanted that. He died two weeks after being put in the home. During his chemo and my visits home, he seemed pretty much himself, though weaker and less active. As far as I was aware, he didn't get the excruciating pain my Mom went through.
But the point of discussing all of this (besides releasing some of my pain), is the fact that I have some measure of guilt associated with both Buck and my Dad in their passing. While I think I made the best decisions at the time, was there something more I could have done?
I don't plan on having another dog. They are great companions, but I don't want to go through the grief of their passing again.
Since I don't get many readers (including my wife), I thought I would add a comment or two on similar situations. I do not approve of abortion in most situations, nor of assisted suicide. In abortion, the girl, young lady, or woman, must either have a hard heart or live with some degree of guilt for their actions. I cannot imagine being in that position. But for their sakes, and those of their unborn child, I hope they decide to keep the child, or in the worst situation, put him/her up for adoption.
Assisted suicide is a little different. In that case, the person makes a choice that they do not want to live, and my libertarian leanings push me to accept their decision. In the terminal stages of a disease, with significant pain, I can understand that choice. But in any other situation, and even in that one, there may be other options for the future. Life has too many ups and downs to bail during one of the downs. If you lose a capability or some functionality, you work around it, just like in old age. It's helping the suicide that I believe is wrong; you should instead try to help them to get through the down time in their life. If you help, how can you live without guilt that maybe they would have recovered and lived years of enjoyable life?
If you read this, thanks for staying with me. Putting down my thoughts has brought me some relief. Maybe some day I will see Buck again...
Monday, September 25, 2017
CBS' New Star Trek Discovery -- A Disappointment
I was eagerly looking forward to the new Star Trek series on CBS. I knew it was going to be on their pay streaming network, so I wasn't sure whether I would continue to follow it after the premier. What does CBS do that isn't on their public channels?
Anyway, I was unhappy with the ads, oops, articles that had come out talking about the new series. They all seemed to highlight the fact that an African-American female, playing First Officer, would be leading a Star Trek series for the first time. No mention of any Captain. In what military does a First Officer lead a unit?
Well, the content of the ads represented the thrust of the series. It appears to be a social justice indoctrination that rubs our nose in white male privilege and supremacy. And at the same time paints military members as idiots. The Captain, as it turns out is Asian female. The Science Officer seems to be an alien, fish maybe? I only saw one white male on the bridge, and he seemed to be a junior officer.
Add to that, when they cut to the Klingons (it's about a new war with the Klingons), you see a peculiarly painted, up close, black Klingon. Other than the fake face paint, that isn't too bad. But then they have a white Klingon ridiculed as unworthy for his color. Not just rubbing our noses in their white male privilege, but white supremacy too.
Personally, I don't like anyone rubbing my nose in their social justice campaigns. I don't mind a diverse set of characters with various races, genders, and aliens. But leave out your social campaigns. I want a science fiction plot I can enjoy without the side distractions. By the way, the Captain seems to do a good job.
Then there's the behavior of their new Star Trek series 'leader,' the First Officer. Her most important action in this episode is to physically assault her Captain, putting her to sleep, then ordering phaser fire on the Klingons in contradiction to her Captain's order. Mutiny. Worse, she only put the Captain to sleep for a few seconds, and the Captain comes back onto the bridge before the fire order is completed. An incompetent mutineer! The episode ends showing the First Officer in the brig.
So we are supposedly going to see the First Officer get out of the brig, save the day against a Klingon attack, and take over running a Federation starship. After she mutinees?
So no. I am not going to pay for any future episodes of this series. And I assume the CBS management that approved this script is putting on the same quality of shows on their new pay channel.
Worse, I had to watch over 15 minutes of the end of 60 Minutes for a late start for the series. Whatever happened to 60 Minutes' investigative journalism? This episode was just a focus group doing mostly Trump bashing. Maybe 50% of the country doesn't watch CBS anymore? And CBS doesn't worry about that segment of their potential audience?
Bottom line, unless you are a social liberal, don't bother with the new Star Trek.
Anyway, I was unhappy with the ads, oops, articles that had come out talking about the new series. They all seemed to highlight the fact that an African-American female, playing First Officer, would be leading a Star Trek series for the first time. No mention of any Captain. In what military does a First Officer lead a unit?
Well, the content of the ads represented the thrust of the series. It appears to be a social justice indoctrination that rubs our nose in white male privilege and supremacy. And at the same time paints military members as idiots. The Captain, as it turns out is Asian female. The Science Officer seems to be an alien, fish maybe? I only saw one white male on the bridge, and he seemed to be a junior officer.
Add to that, when they cut to the Klingons (it's about a new war with the Klingons), you see a peculiarly painted, up close, black Klingon. Other than the fake face paint, that isn't too bad. But then they have a white Klingon ridiculed as unworthy for his color. Not just rubbing our noses in their white male privilege, but white supremacy too.
Personally, I don't like anyone rubbing my nose in their social justice campaigns. I don't mind a diverse set of characters with various races, genders, and aliens. But leave out your social campaigns. I want a science fiction plot I can enjoy without the side distractions. By the way, the Captain seems to do a good job.
Then there's the behavior of their new Star Trek series 'leader,' the First Officer. Her most important action in this episode is to physically assault her Captain, putting her to sleep, then ordering phaser fire on the Klingons in contradiction to her Captain's order. Mutiny. Worse, she only put the Captain to sleep for a few seconds, and the Captain comes back onto the bridge before the fire order is completed. An incompetent mutineer! The episode ends showing the First Officer in the brig.
So we are supposedly going to see the First Officer get out of the brig, save the day against a Klingon attack, and take over running a Federation starship. After she mutinees?
So no. I am not going to pay for any future episodes of this series. And I assume the CBS management that approved this script is putting on the same quality of shows on their new pay channel.
Worse, I had to watch over 15 minutes of the end of 60 Minutes for a late start for the series. Whatever happened to 60 Minutes' investigative journalism? This episode was just a focus group doing mostly Trump bashing. Maybe 50% of the country doesn't watch CBS anymore? And CBS doesn't worry about that segment of their potential audience?
Bottom line, unless you are a social liberal, don't bother with the new Star Trek.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)